Guest Author: Victoria Davis

Litter box habits are often misunderstood, even by people who love cats. Misconceptions can lead to messy accidents and a stressful situation. You may even be hurting your cat without knowing it. Check out the following three myths about cats and their litter boxes!

Myth #1: A cat who won’t use the litter box is being bad.

Cat behaviors are dictated by animal instinct, not emotion. This means cats don’t pee on your rugs out of spite, and they don’t do it to irritate you. They might avoid the litter box for other reasons, including stressful events, separation anxiety, disputes over territory, or physical pain, but being a bad kitty isn’t one of them.

Cats want to use their litter boxes, so when they don’t, something is very wrong. It’s a symptom of a larger problem, meaning there’s an unknown trigger that caused the unwanted behavior. That’s why it’s so important to work with your veterinarian to treat (or rule out) any medical issues first. Once your veterinarian determines your cat is physically healthy, your next step is to figure out why your cat is stressed and unhappy: Has anything recently changed in your life? Do you regularly clean and disinfect his litter box? Are stray cats yowling outside your window? If you’re dealing with territorial issues, you can try using Feliway‘s multicat formula. Switching litter box locations or avoiding scented litter could help too. You may also want to talk to a cat-behavior specialist if you’re at your wit’s end. The sooner you identify the trigger, the sooner you’ll be able to resolve the situation.

“Cats want to use their litter boxes, so when they don’t, something is very wrong.”


Myth #2: Cats prefer to do their business in private.

There’s some truth to this statement, but it’s not entirely accurate. When it comes to litter box locations, cats prefer a place that’s accessible and safe. Your cat has to have easy access to a litter box, meaning it’s not too far away and not too hard to reach. While your cat won’t want to do his business in a noisy and busy area, he’s also not going to like climbing down two flights of stairs to get to a litter box in the basement.

As for safety, a cat is pretty vulnerable while urinating or defecating. If he doesn’t have a clear view of the space around his litter box, he won’t be able to watch for predators. That’s why many cats prefer not to use a litter box inside a closet or a shower stall. Covered litter boxes are also problematic for this reason. While they’re as private as you can get, they completely block out the view of the room and provide only one opening with no other ways to escape. A predator (or other household cat) can simply crouch around the corner, waiting for the perfect time to pounce.

For a cat, the ideal location for a litter box is in a low-traffic area near the main part of the house, offers an unobstructed view of the room, and provides for multiple escape routes. You may be tempted to disregard your cat’s needs and place the litter box where it can’t be seen or smelled by people. Don’t. Try these simple solutions to eliminate odors instead. If you like the idea of a covered box because you’re worried about litter scattering all over the floor, there are ways to keep your home clean without compromising your cat’s happiness – like using a top-notch litter mat.

Gray tabby kitten using litter box

Myth #3: Cats will happily share a litter box.

Even if you have cats who play with the same toys and eat from each other’s bowls, they may not want to share litter boxes. Is it possible for two cats to share one box? Yes, but they won’t be happy about it! Cats are not only territorial, they also adhere to a social hierarchy. You’ll see this playing out when each cat gravitates toward a favorite sleeping spot. Top cat gets the best bed which is usually higher than the others or nearer to a source of warmth. Even though sleeping spots will shift for various reasons, such as time of day, weather, or even changes to a room’s layout, each cat will have a certain territory to call their own.

Urine and feces are not only a visible territory marker, it’s a smelly one too. Some cats won’t cover their poop. Others will run to the litter box right after another finishes just to make a point. Dominant cats can even block the path to a litter box so no one else can use it, and if a cat regularly gets ambushed while urinating or defecating, he’ll soon develop litter box aversion and potential urinate elsewhere or start spraying. Nature’s Miracle does a great job of getting rid of cat urine.

The Humane Society of the United States recommends one litter box per cat, plus one more. Everyone gets their own with an extra one to spare, and a dominant cat can’t guard two boxes at once. Even if you’re lucky enough to have cats who are willing to share a litter box, providing a second choice will make them happier. You may even notice your cats preferring to urinate in one box while defecating in the other!


About the author

Victoria Davis is a mother, daughter and forever a cat lover. She is the co-founder of Smiling Paws Pets and a huge advocate for fair animal treatment and wellbeing.

Want to make over your litter box area? Check out these tips to transform your litter box area.

This blog contains affiliate links. For more information about third-party advertising on this site, please click here.

You might also enjoy these articles…

RSVP Photo Banner for Cancer Care Paw event

A Paws for Wellness: The CancerCare PAW Program and the Support It Offers to Those Fighting Cancer

In the grueling fight against cancer, patients often seek comfort in the steadfast company of their pets. The joyous wag of a dog’s tail or the gentle nuzzle of a cat can speak volumes in silent, understanding support. This unbreakable bond has not gone unnoticed by CancerCare, which has embarked on helping patients who are also the proud caregivers to their beloved animal companions. The Pet Assistance and Wellness Program (PAW) by CancerCare honors the role pets play in the lives of the patients by providing a much-needed support cushion during their treatment.

lonely young girl holding a cat who is offering emotional support to the girl.

How Cats Alleviate Loneliness

The global pandemic has brought loneliness into sharp focus, shedding light on a long-standing struggle for many. Lockdowns and social distancing have unveiled the emotional toll, underscoring the importance of companionship. In these isolated times, pets, particularly cats, have emerged as silent champions, providing much-needed solace and companionship.

Cat DIY Hammock

DIY Cat Hammock

Looking for a fun, feline-centric project for the weekend? Try this DIY Hammock! Crafting a cozy haven for your feline friend doesn't have to be complicated or expensive. In fact, with a little creativity and some basic supplies, you can create a stylish and...
Rolling cat cute green eyes looking happy with a content facial expression - The Catnip Times

Study Finds Cats Have 276 Facial Expressions

Cats, our enigmatic feline friends, have long been masters of the subtle art of communication. A recent study, published in the journal Behavioral Processes, delves deep into the world of cat expressions, uncovering a whopping 276 distinct facial cues when these furry companions interact with each other.

Domestic cat looking at cupcakes.

Surprising Foods You Need to Keep Away from Your Cat

Cats are curious creatures by nature, and this inquisitive disposition often extends to their diet. However, as pet parents, it is incumbent upon us to be vigilant about what goes into their feeding bowls. Keeping them away from potentially harmful foods is not just...
Calico shelter cat sleeping outdoors at Largo di Torre Argentina, Rome, Italy

Largo di Torre Argentina: Where History Meets Cat Sanctuary

Nestled amidst the timeless beauty of Rome lies a treasure trove that marries history with the heartwarming presence of ‘gatti,’ or cats in Italian. The Area Sacra in Largo di Torre Argentina, an archaeological gem, has recently flung open its gates to human visitors after being shrouded in mystery for almost a century. What makes this site truly unique? It’s not just the ancient ruins that attract visitors from around the world, but the thriving community of feral cats that has called this place home for the last 100 years.